top of page
Search

The Monk, the Dove and the Piano

3 days ago
6 min read

14 Nov 2026 · @Katherine

Written from a pianist's perspective, and as associate artist for exams and studio concerts, with the young musician in mind.


The room where reading counts


An exam room has its own silence: straight-backed chairs, the soft tapping of the examiner's keyboard, a piano that looks bigger than the one at home. I know it well. As a pianist, and as associate artist for exams and studio concerts, I have sat beside many young musicians just before the first note.


In that silence I can tell at once who has read their music and who has only copied it. The reader settles, the way you know your own street in the dark. The copier holds their breath and hopes memory won't slip.


A cautionary tale


Some years ago, a young pianist I was working with sat a piano exam having learnt the pieces by memory and imitation rather than by reading. I begged her to play from the score. She insisted on playing from memory. Weeks later the report arrived, with one sentence that stood out. It was aimed squarely at me:

"I don't know why your teacher lets you play from memory."

The examiner had heard it at once: notes not quite on the page, dynamics and articulations that had vanished, bars that were identical apart from their pitch played with the wrong rhythms. It was music remembered, misremembered, stumbled over and got lost in, but never truly read.

She learnt the hard way that memory is not a substitute for reading. And I learnt that some students can't be talked out of a shortcut, however hard you plead. They have to learn the hard way. I'd much rather you learnt it from her story instead.


Why memory isn't enough


Memory is beautiful. One smell or sound can bring back a whole afternoon.


But it is also a trickster: it fades, rearranges and changes details without telling you.


Only music that has been carefully read, analysed and processed truly sticks.


Fast, shallow learning fades.


This isn't a new discovery. Long ago, some very patient people decided memory was not enough.


The monastery and the dove

Picture a cold stone monastery around the year 600, in the Early Middle Ages (sometimes called the Dark Ages). Candles flicker. Monks are singing.


This was the time of Pope Gregory the Great. The Church's chants were later named "Gregorian chant" after him, and medieval artists painted him with a dove at his ear, whispering the melodies from heaven. But a system of notation had not yet been developed. Every chant lived only in memory, passed from singer to singer.


You can guess what happened. Like a game of whispers, each singer changed a note or added a little "interpretation". Two hundred years later, the same chant sounded different in every monastery in Europe.


So the monks, with quill and ink, began drawing tiny marks above the words to show where the melody went. Century by century, those marks became the notes you read today. Every time you open your score, you hold the answer to a problem that took a thousand years to solve.



Two shortcuts through the forest


Fourteen centuries later, the score is still where music begins. My studies took me to London, Manhattan and Moscow. Each teaching approach was slightly different, but all rested on a single premise: the score is the primary source of all information.*


Yet, whether it's a cumulative effect or there really are more students doing it, more and more young musicians seem mesmerised by two tantalising shortcuts that take us straight back to the 600s:

  • Copying YouTube videos: imitating someone's hands, or falling-note animations, until the piece sticks.

  • Freeze-memorising the lesson: trying to remember how the piece looked and sounded in the lesson instead of reading it. The piece gets "snap frozen", stuck as it was when the lesson ended.


A traveller who always follows someone else's footprints never learns to read the map. Here is where these two dead-end paths lead:

  • Every new piece starts from zero, and sight-reading is in almost every exam.

  • Other people's mistakes become yours, and unlearning them takes ages.

  • You stop hearing your own sound.

  • It crumbles under pressure. In the exam room, finger-memory has nothing to hold on to. The score does.

  • Lessons get stuck hunting for notes instead of making music.


In Preliminary to Grade 4, it's normal to still be finding your way, so now is the time to change paths.


From Grade 5 to Grade 8 the road gets steeper, and students still taking shortcuts struggle to learn even six pieces a year.


The trap of needing to be shown


These shortcuts set one more trap, and it can catch teachers as well as students. A student who can't read needs someone to show them every new piece. A teacher who shows notes instead of teaching reading becomes the only way in, and creates their own demand.


A word for this is codependency. Picture a bike mechanic who fixes your flat tyre every week but never shows you how to pump it up: you'd be back at the shop forever. In medicine it's called supplier-induced demand.


A good teacher works the other way, becoming less and less necessary for the notes, so lessons can be about everything beyond them.


The gift of a generous teacher is musical literacy.


The music is the map


So how do you become a reader? Slowly at first, with the patience of monks with quills: one bar, one hand, and no keys until step 6.

  1. Look first. Check the clef, key and time signatures, and any sharps or flats. Circle anything that's easy to miss.

  2. Clap and count the rhythm out loud.

  3. Say the note names out loud.

  4. Say the finger numbers and waggle each finger in the air.

  5. Say the note names while waggling the right fingers.

  6. Chain it. Forwards: play the first note, then the first two, then the first three. Backwards: play the last note, then the last two, then the last three, always playing to the end of the bar.

  7. Bridge. Play the bar and stop on the first note of the next one.

Then the other hand, then the next bar. It looks slow, but nothing needs unlearning, so it's secretly the fastest way, and the best foundation for sight-reading.


When the two hands meet


Once each hand knows its part, it's time to put them together. This approach comes from the Royal Conservatory of Music in Toronto.

  1. Tap both hands' rhythms on the closed lid or your lap, counting or calling out the dynamics.

  2. Play one hand and tap the other. Then swap.

  3. Chain it hands together, forwards and backwards, beat by beat.

  4. Bridge to the next bar.

  5. Check with a Noteflight practice track (slow it down if you need to), and fix any mistakes straight away, before they settle in.


The boy who practised only the hard bits

Not every story is a warning. A young student recently played me a three-page sonata he had learnt in three weeks. His secret? "I only practise the hard bits." He could, because he reads his music and listens to himself, so he knew exactly where the difficult corners were. That is where the map leads.


Listening, and the long line of hands

Reading doesn't mean you stop listening. Listen to great pianists often, but like a detective, not a photocopier. Listen for interpretation (each performer's choices), tone (the colour of the sound) and syntax (how phrases are built, where they breathe and where they land). To check your notes, use Noteflight practice tracks, never YouTube.


Learn the notes between lessons, and each lesson becomes a small concert: you play for your teacher, then the real work begins on sound, phrasing and character. Circle anything still stubborn, to look at after you play.


That is where the deepest learning happens. In London, I studied with the pianist Julian Jacobson, whose line of teachers runs eight generations back to Beethoven: a long chain of hands, each passing something precious on. Every good teacher hopes to pass on something like that, but it can only go to hands that already know the notes.


Back to the quiet room



If you haven't already done so, one day soon you'll sit in that exam room. Memory may wobble; it always does a little. But if you have truly read your music, you'll have something steadier: the score inside you, as the monks had it on their pages.


A copy fades. What you have read and understood is yours for good.


A note for parents


It may feel slower at first. Within weeks, students learn faster, play with understanding and get more from every lesson. Your encouragement between lessons makes a huge difference.



* I know that some students face genuine barriers to reading, such as vision impairment or a learning difference. For them, there are other ways into the score: braille music notation, or notation software that highlights each note as it plays, to help the eyes track along the page. Talk to your teacher about what would help.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2020 by KATHERINE DAY

bottom of page